Hazrat Muaviyah [r.a] Aur Tareekhi Haqaiq By Shaykh Mufti Taqi Usmani A FAMOUS BOOK WRITTEN IN DEFENCE OF HAZRAT MUAVIA [R.A] Hazrat Ameer Muaviyah [r.a] Aur Tareekhi Rivayaat By Shaykh Muhammad. Ameer Muawiya Aur Tareekhi Haqaiq Author Mufti Taqi Usmani. May Click to Download Click to Read on Scribd. Post a Comment. For More Islamic Books For More Islamic Books Visit For More I.

Author: Samubei Kajind
Country: Dominica
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Literature
Published (Last): 14 February 2009
Pages: 296
PDF File Size: 2.88 Mb
ePub File Size: 7.23 Mb
ISBN: 260-3-27184-371-9
Downloads: 74990
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Nikree

And then he tried to convert the muslim khilafat into malookiat. My point is that if muawiyz want to quote an example it should be haqiaq good example. Wa alaikum us salam wa Rahmatullah. If some Sahaba had something wrong, Allah will not ask us about that but if they were really acquitted from that, we will be held responsible in front of Allah for believing in reports transmitted through doubtful channels.

If the answer is yes, we should go for it but if the answer is no, why to conduct a debate on an issue that has not been settled during last 14 centuries.

The views presented in the books belong to their authors and they are responsible for providing the answer raised on their work. If someone blames our father, should we accept his accusations without any assessment? However, information available through Tawatur is something different and exceptional.

All other history books of subsequent periods were written based on Tabari’s work. But the issue is that we do not have reliable and undisputed information about such incidents.

Therefore, there is no charge of revolt against him. I’m not in a position to do so. It is completely wrong to compare him with culprits like Zia or Musharaf. Therefore, the issue becomes extremely grave. The approach of Tabari was to compile all the narrations whether authentic or not in a chronological order. Whatever is the opinion of Sunnis, Shias or Khawarij on such issues, it is no more than a theory based on doubtful reports because Sunni reports are not acceptable to Shia and vice versa.


Hazrat Muawiya( R. A) Aur Tarikhi Haqaiq

The unchallenged information could only be the one which is available to us by ” Tawatur please see the link below ” which is not sufficient to tareekih us a complete picture of the incident. Respected Sister Assalam o alaikum wa Rahmatullah Many hqaiq for your kind words and comments about my books. I read the book thoroughly but I am sorry instead of making me satisfy it has made me more doubtful. You can take each narration one by one and see the biographies of their narrators compiled by the scholars of Hadith.

Musharrif ruled for 9 years because he is very patient. We are free to form opinions within this life. If we accept the narrations portraying himself as a dictator, the matter will not remain limited to him. Many akr for your kind words and comments about my books.

I’ll sincerely advise you to leave this matter to Allah.

Hazrat Ameer Muaviyah [r.a] Aur Tareekhi Rivayaat By Shaykh Muhammad Saqib Risalpuri – Free Books

Only that person will reach at a tareehki conclusion who was present at that occasion and bears eyewitness of an incident. On the other side, if we keep a bad opinion about the companions and they were free from such accusations, Allah will definitely hold us accountable.

This is the history and it cant be denied. Send at mubashirnazir gmail. But I’ll advise you to not rely on me and conduct your amee study. Details of this procedure are available here: If you study the history of Tabari for such years, you’ll find people in the Sanad of all negative reports about the companions.

Don’t hesitate to share your questions and comments. Search the Website New. When the matter is only an issue of doubtful reports, why should we form our opinions based on them. Tabari is available on the following link. I respect the author of this book but it seems like he is just playing with the words.


If a matter with such doubtful information is presented to any court in the world, the judge will not be able to decide the matter and will acquit the suspect based on the benefit of doubt despite of the fact that the suspect and relevant witnesses are available in his court.

New articles and books are added this website on 1 st of each month. I agree with you that narrations from such people should not be accepted in other matters even it is in favor of our view.

Tareekkhi riwaiat is not authentic because the rawi is shia and the same time another riwaiat by a shia rawi is authentic because it favours his opinion When I conducted such research, I found that almost all reports containing negative information about such companions was reported by one or more of the five narrators mentioned above.

We also know that all such people disguised themselves in mainstream Muslims. As far as I’ve studied the history, I’ve reached at the conclusion that it is not possible to settle a disputed issue based on a historical reports. Nobody believes that Sahaba were free from sin. You can check by yourselves in the “History of Tabari ” that all reports portraying muawia sleazy picture of the companions are reported by only five persons and all of them are considered as “liars “.

It is also reported muasiya some narrations that he changed his decision once he found that a rule has already been established there. Other than that, there is nothing except theories of different people. Allah, in the name of, the Most Affectionate, the Eternally Merciful. Questions are good for your intellectual health!!! Even we cannot reach at a decisive conclusion about events happening in our life.